Originally sent to subscribers on November 13, 2026.
Looking for strong comedians/improvisers.
Check.
Able to tap in to subtle, naturalistic moments.
Check.
This character is having a conversation with a close friend they bump into at the supermarket…
I think I've got thi—
…while doing the Can-Can.
🤦🏻♂️
***
I'm sitting in a Midtown casting office reviewing the specs for Clark, a character in an upcoming holiday ad for a large grocery chain.
I've been invited to auditions requiring dance before. But I think I was invited less because I was a fit for the commercial and more because the casting director needed a laugh. During the last two auditions I don't think she even pressed record. That, and before saying “Action” she plopped on the couch with a glass of Chard and muttered to herself, “this should be good.”
You may recall the last time I danced for an audition. I say dance, but that's a strong word. It implies I moved in such a way that someone accidentally entering the room would have thought, I've interrupted a dance audition. In my case, they would have thought, Oh god. Call an ambulance. I did not book that one.
There was another audition I haven't disclosed. It was a self-tape so the shame was private and—had I not started writing this paragraph—would have remained so. The spec called for “a single dad in his early-to-mid 40s. Think Jake Johnson.” I donned my lone flannel shirt and didn't shower or shave.. So far, so good. “He has a natural dancing ability but it should never feel overly professional.” The “natural dancing ability” is a stretch, but “never overly professional” is my wheelhouse. Despite not feeling like a fit I gave it a shot.
I sent it in and never heard back. And recently, I found out why. They didn't want Jake Johnson. They wanted a Baryshnikov with a man bun. I'd say c'est la vie if it didn't sound like a ballet maneuver.
So you can understand why I'm not exactly thrilled to be in another waiting room for another dancing commercial. I didn't see the previous actors who went in, but the sounds on the other side of the door tell me it must have been a cheer squad.
The door to the casting room opens and a pair of actors exit, radiating pride for having executed what I assume was a perfect number. Their faces glisten like they've just come off the pickleball court.
She dabs her face with a towel she brought from home.“That was SO much fun. Were you a Rockette in a previous life.” She laughs and skips to the restroom.
“Ha!” he shouts, projecting like a Broadway star. He fans himself with both hands. “Baby just got his steps in!” he says, singing the last part.
I look around expecting to see someone bringing them flowers and wonder if I have time to change into something more comfortable. Like a leotard.
I Google “How to Can-Can” while the casting director looks at the sign-in sheet. And then “How to stretch.”
“Mia, Anthony. You're next!”
Mia leaps up and claps like she was a cheer captain in high school.
I rock myself into a standing position.
“Hi! I'm Mia!” she says extending her hand. “It's soo nice to meet you!”
“Nice to meet you too,” I say, trying to ignore the sudden kink in my neck. I gesture for her to enter first, less to be chivalrous and more so she can't see me hike up my jeans.
Seated behind the camera and posterboard script are the director and three others who I assume are agency representatives. I say assume because they're doing things agency representatives do, which is nothing. They don't look up or say anything when we enter the room. If you were watching from outside the room, it would look like we just interrupted three different Zoom meetings.
I look around the cameras to make eye contact. “Hello!”
One of them clears their throat. The other one mumbles something that sounds like, “you're on mute.”
The casting director gives us our blocking. “You're two friends who see each other at the store and have a brief conversation. These are your baskets. And here are your cans.”
She hands us each a makeshift hand basket—an acrylic bin wth a festive ribbon for a handle—and four La Croix soda waters.
She returns to her position behind the camera and hits record. “Okay, let's run one. No Can-Can this time.”
Thank you, Jesus. Maybe this won't be as terrible as I feared?
The first take goes well. Mostly because I don't have to break out my moves. I improv a few lines and the director chuckles, which I take as a good sign. The agency people look at me like I'm in the wrong room, which I take as a bad sign.
The director removes her glasses and rubs her eyes. “On this one, Mia, you're like really excited to be there. You're like the former cheer captain of your school.”
“Quick question?” I say.
“Oh…yeah?” the director says, in a tone that says you're still here?
“Any changes for me, or should I just play it the same?”
“Sure.”
We run it a few more times. And at this point I'm feeling pretty good, like maybe I actually have a shot at this thing. With no guidance, I'm free to goof around. My character says, “Why do they call it the Can-Can sale?” Mia's says, “because of all the cans.” But then I add, “I don't get it.” And I get a laugh from the agency. The holy grail of callbacks. I'm feeling better about my chances. Like I might actually have a shot at getting booked. And then something happens.
The casting director comes closer and speaks quietly, the way you'd rally the troops before one final defense of the Alamo, “On this one, we're just going to do the Can-Can. No scene, just dance.”
And then she solemnly puts her hand on my forearm. “Break a leg.”
I nod and brace myself for the last stand, knowing I'm going down having accomplished what any comedic actor would kill for—an agency chuckle. It was good while it lasted.
The casting director stops and does an about-face, pivoting on her heel. “Oh! I almost forgot!”
I'm hoping she's going to say, “Just kidding, you booked it!”
“Make sure to put your hands on your hips and smile. Like the Rockettes.” She puts her hands on her hips and smiles. Like the Rockettes.
It's a good thing she said that. I'd hate for the director to be reviewing the tapes later and think, If he'd only had his hands on his hips…
I've never done the Can-Can before, but I assume it's supposed to be done in unison. “Which leg do you wanna start with?” I ask Mia, like we're at a Ren faire, perusing a tray of turkey legs. I add, “Left or right?”
“Let's do left,” she says. “Since you said that first.”
I don't even hear the casting director call action. All I'm thinking is knee-kick-knee-kick and keep my hands on my hips. That, and how embarrassed I'll be after I die from trying to kick too high. Whoever finds my phone is going to see my internet history and think what's with this guy and the Rockettes? Is he some sort of pervert?”
I throw up the left knee. Then the full kick. I've never seen my foot that high before. Not when I did Tae Kwon Do as a kid and could kick high. Or when I did karate in college and could kick less high. I'm surprised, but also amazed. The director has to be thinking, Funny and he dances? Where has he been all this time? With my confidence soaring, it's time for the right knee, and then boom, the whole gam. I'm beaming. Not only because the dance calls for it but because I'm experiencing true joy. I'm not playing a Rockette.
I am a Rockette.
And that's when I see Mia's leg. Or rather, her knee. I have to tilt my head to see the rest. Somehow, despite being a whole head shorter than me, her foot's higher than mine. Higher than I new was physically possible. With her thigh pressed against her chest, and her toe pointed straight to the heavens, she gives me a smile that says, “top this.”
***
I left the callback a little sorer than when I entered, but glad that I went. I didn't book this dancing role. But someday I'll land one.
It's a stretch goal.